Wool Blanket Vs Wool Sweater?


YABBER

Scout
Joined
May 9, 2011
Messages
211
Likes
168
Location
Long Island NY
Hello all,

I have been shopping around for some new cold weather gear and was wondering if investing in a really good wool sweater is a better choice than a expensive wool blanket. I have used the military surplus blanket before but just really never took a liking so I would be forced to buy a hudson bay for a big chunk of change. So, just looking for some advice as to which is the better investment, sweater or blanket.
 
A sweater you can wear when it's cold out.

A blanket you can sleep with, make into a sleeping bag, wear as a coat, turn into the "jetpack," etc...

Check out Abo4ster's wool blanket tech videos and that will help you understand some of the benefits of a blanket.

Have you also seen the Italian Military blankets? I like them a WHOLE lots more than the US Army wool blankets.
 
For myself, it depends on the level of activity. My cable knit sweater breathes better than my blanket shirt during a hike, but while squirrel hunting or sitting at camp, the blanket is king. I also layer different sweaters, a thin merino v-neck, possibly argyle, with a larger fishermans sweater over builds up nice lofty insulation.
 
Honestly, I'd go with a good shirt jac. Always wear my shirt jac....My wool blanket has many types of replacements depending on conditions and intended activity.
 
not sure what my advice is worth on this one...

i'm partial to soft, high quality wool, whether for longjohns or sweaters. one of kevin kinney's boreal jackets would be awesome too. i just like wool on my skin when i'm out in the cold and wet. fleece is close, but stinky.
for wool, there is no substitute.

a wool blanket would be nice for laying by a fire (if i slept on the ground), sitting by the fire (which i like to do), or just wrapping around me as i go about my morning routine in camp. however, there are lots of substitutes. a swedish or italian one (if you can find them) or even a cheaper, mixed-wool blanket (like a usgi one, 70/30), could all work. i've even worn my poncho liner as a blanket to warm up in the morning.

i am also partial to "light", as in weight. a good wool blanket like you're suggesting is going to be in the 3-5lb range, and that, for me, is too much for camping (i do a lot of canoeing, but it often involves portages). for something to sleep in, i'm sold on a down bag.

i'd go with the sweater, not the blanket.

just my penny's worth.
 
I like sleeping in layers of wool clothing. I stay warmer that way than with a wool blanket.

My opinion is that clothing is so versatile I like carrying extra layers of clothing rather than carrying a wool blanket. It’s a lot less bulky and lighter.

I would not do this with synthetic clothing.

That's just my opinion.

Geoff
 
Sweater if you intend to use it while hiking, as the weight and size of a wool blanket is probally more than you want in a backpack. But if weight isnt an issue a blanket would be real nice.
 
hello. just wanted to give my 2 cents worth. i am lucky to have both wool blankets and sweaters. i love them all. i have slept w just 2 blankets and was plenty warm in to the lower 40s. w/o a fire. on a back yard camp-out with a tent. i had a u.s. army blanket and an italian army blanket. also ive worn a 5 button army sweater with a woolrich shirt-jac out in the upper 30s with just a tshirt on under it. hope this helps.
 
Honestly, I'd go with a good shirt jac. Always wear my shirt jac....My wool blanket has many types of replacements depending on conditions and intended activity.

I'm with kgd, I have a couple wool blankets and I honestly can't bring myself to carry them when I have lighter, warmer options available. For me my wool sweaters/shirts get far more use than the blankets so my inclination would be to invest in a good wool clothing layer before something like a Hudson Bay blanket.
 
Used both a "Wooly-pully" sweater from the days in the Corps, ( I gave it to my youngest son) & US issue wool blanket. I still have that blanket & I been out of the USMC for 26 years.
So my answer would be.... Blanket. Both sons can fight over it when I go away.
;)

As was said earlier...Blanket = More uses.
:)
Enjoy!
:)
 
Sweaters in the USA 'n' Jumpers in the UK!

*Note Before reading my mindless tripe, I obviously have a wool bias, so keep that in mind. I’m a novice bushcrafter/woodsman, but I have spent considerable time in the cold weather.

For the sake of brevity, buy a nice 100% wool sweater, and you won’t be sorry. It’s a great addition to the surplus blanket that you already have. As time goes by, you can always add to your kit.

If you have trouble reading rather wordy threads, I implore you to stop at this point. You’ve been forewarned.

Large bulky wool sweaters with chunky knits make fabulous outerwear when covered with a light protective shell. I vary mine by knit as the weather dictates. Tight weave, lose weave, tight weave so it creates pockets of trapped dead airspace, which I’ve found to be the key to insulating myself.

I do not believe in relying on one item, ie, a wool blanket to keep me warm. I use a system so if one’s compromised, the others are still fine. The blanket is nothing more than added insurance to an already good system.

It’s hard to find military gear in sizes beyond medium, so most of my sweaters are civilian. Be wary of military surplus sweaters. They're often not 100% wool, and they frequently have their tags missing or the label has had the print laundered off. At least with civilian gear, it's usually labeled properly. If there is no label to back up how the garment feels, I will not purchase it.

033-2.jpg

037-2.jpg


Here's a sample of my civilian & military sweaters/jumpers. Keep in mind that I purchased this and more over a span of 20 years. *Note the varying weave from drawer to drawer.

001-4.jpg

003-4.jpg


The huge knit traps air. Clunky knits are nice because if I get too warm I can unzip/button my outer shell, and the wind gets in, circulates well, and cools me rather quickly. J.G. Glover sweater in photo.

004-2.jpg


A word of warning, never wear loosely knit sweaters as outerwear while going through the bush. The thorns, brush, and branches will tear them apart. They’re fine for camp in a clearing or on a trail unfettered by encroaching brush, but in the bush they need a protective outer shell. Bush battle scars.

027.jpg

026-1.jpg



Military surplus wool jeep sweaters aren’t too bad, but they have a rather snug fit, so I wear them as a middle layer. The knit’s not too tight, so it creates a lot of medium sized air pockets.

017-4.jpg

020-1.jpg


Military surplus Italian San Marco wool sweater has a weave that’s fairly tight. These are rather form fitting as well, but not too tight.

018-1.jpg

019.jpg


I have a couple of alpaca sweaters as well. They seem just as warm as wool, but are significantly lighter.

002-3.jpg


If you’re not going to be generating much perspiration and your activities are in dry weather, a wool sweater is probably good enough to bulk up your cold weather gear. However, I find, as a cyclist, and sometimes woodsman/bushcrafter that wool doesn’t work at all for me unless it makes up my entire wardrobe. Once cotton, nylon, or poly undergarments are wet, the wool sweater will not keep me warm, so I use wool right down to my skin.

In addition to what I’ve previously shown in photos. I wear the following undergarments according to the weather and activity level I’m going to engage in.

Wool underwear/knickers with Mora for scale:

015-4.jpg

016-2.jpg


Wool long johns:

010-5.jpg

007-5.jpg


I’m not a big fan of WoolPower because they’re only 60% wool. I will use them since I have two pairs in the 200 gram weight and one pair of 400 gram. They don’t like anything hot. I’ve burned quite a few holes in them, and they’re rather expensive! It was an impulse buy, and I didn’t read the fine print. I assumed that they were 100% wool.

013-3.jpg

Here you can see the terrycloth knit:
012-4.jpg



All the above undergarments/knickers are very thin, but extremely warm, and with exception to the WoolPower long johns, they’re all 100% wool.

Why I don't like WoolPower garments. In the following photo, one can see the results of what a tiny hot cinder that fell off my cigarette did. The cinder was pin head sized, yet look at the hole. The 100% merino woolskins beneath weren't affected. *Book of matches for scale.

025-1.jpg


My final shell layer will depend upon weather and activity. The three on the left are Gore-Tex shells followed by my genuine article Navy surplus pea coat, and several 100% Melton wool greatcoats from various military factions throughout Europe. In the second photo, note how long the greatcoats are. Some of them are 57 inches from the top of the collar to the hem of the skirt. These are great for blocking wind off my legs as they fall almost to the tops of my 10-inch boots. I can sit wherever I want without worry of conduction sucking the heat out of me or getting a wet bum.

021.jpg

024-1.jpg

022.jpg


Some of my wool over trousers as well:

011-5.jpg

010-2.jpg


That gear keeps me warm, and I can layer according to what the situation warrants. Hence a wool blanket is only an addition to my gear.

The best part of wool sweaters is that in everyday life, they’re more versatile than a wool blanket because I can wear them in the real world wherever I go, and they won’t generate quizzical stares like donning a wool blanket as though it’s a serape or something… That’s my dollar and two cents.

If you got this far, I hope it’s given you some ideas and thanks for reading.
Cheers,
Cheap&Squeaky
 
Last edited:
*Note Before reading my mindless tripe, I obviously have a wool bias, so keep that in mind.

That's putting it mildly. That is one awesome wool collection. Right down to the undies which look awesome. Do you have herders in you ancestry? Maybe you were a sheep in another life time. Thanks for taking the time to show us.:)
 
Cheap'n'squeaky,


You make a great argument in favour or sweaters. After reading your reply my wife is now thinking of getting a new wool sweater to, so I guess you helped make up my mind via my wifes oponion.:1:
 
I love my wool blankets, and clothes. My advise would be to save ten bucks more then a blanket would cost and hit up the goodwill for a wool shirt or sweater. Really 2 differant animals IMO. One is truely a wearable, and the other is sleeping gear. Wool blankets resist holes from embers better then a synthetic bag, insulate when wet, and are very durable for woods use.

I know folks wear their blankets, but I prefer not too, just not my bag baby. I use a wool blanket 3x a week at work for my rack, and almost every trip in the winter months dictated by shelter etc....
 
Last edited:
One suggestion I can offer is to buy a very high quality coat or sweater and make your own blanket also of very high quality, but much less expensive by crocheting or knitting. Simple crochet is very easy to learn, and you have a choice of wonderful yarns to work with; buy superwash wool if you don't want shrinkage, or weave it very loosely and felt it up if you do. You can crochet a good-sized blanket in a weekend.
 
get a blanket and then cut a slit in the middle for your head and wear it like a poncho. You can use a string to tie it around you closed, or just let it flap around.
My 2 cents.

If the OP did this with a vintage Hudson Bay blanket, I would have to give him a few noogies and punch buggies at the next meet-up just for the silliness of it....
 
This was pretty comfortable to sleep in, doubly so if you're sleeping in front of a fire, the hood can sheild your face from embers. Courtesy of mi madre, made out of two military wool blankets.

6837342599_e15b4f847a.jpg


Inspired from what this guy got, but I'm 6'6" so I knew I had to go custom, haha.

http://www.bushcraftusa.com/forum/showthread.php?t=51805

But you might find something your size from where this guy got his pull over.
 
Can you guys suggest some good manufactures of wool sweaters?

Also, which wool sweater is your favorite?

Geoff

I really liked my Swanndri ranger shirt for its material weight and warmth. It was a good mid-weight layering item, but I unfortunately lost it. I replaced it with a woolrich shirt jac which I like just as much. They were both about the same price. The Swanndri was 100% wool, the Woolrich is 80% wool/20% nylon. I can't tell the difference.

This is the swanndri one I use now.

http://www.woolrich.com/woolrich/br...e&icCategory=cat10011&icProduct=6132&icSort=\

I think I prefer the button up to the pullover a bit more, although I was convinced the pullover was the way to go when I owned the rangershirt. Anyhow, I'm very happy with this one. Good on its own until 32 oF or so and a great mid-layer under a heavy wool anorak or shell.
 
I just got a camp coat from Empire Canvas that I love. he has several offerings, and is a vendor here on BCUSA. Woolrich is another brand I'm quite fond of.
 
Buy both. A blanket is so versatile and wool sweaters can be had cheap at thrift stores. Just bought another wool sweater at a thrift store for $4.98 last week.
 
Can you guys suggest some good manufactures of wool sweaters?

Also, which wool sweater is your favorite?

Geoff


I do have my favorite sweater manufacturers, but they’re very expensive. Filson is nice and they do have some products made in the USA, but they're brutally expensive, and one has to be careful, they've begun importing a lot of things, but charge as though they're still made here in the USA. The UK and Northern European countries make some rather nice wool sweaters, but again, they’re rather expensive. Woolrich used to be nice. If it's a second hand score, fine, but remember, Woolrich is no longer made in Pennsylvania, they're now made in China. Made in China is fine in my opinion providing I pay Chinese prices, which should be about a nickle. I’d suggest second hand stores to anybody that’s just starting out in wool.

In my area, The Goodwill is the most expensive second hand store. When I go to other second hand shops, it’s like 50% off to a clearance sale compared to The Goodwill. Army Navy shops can be a boon or a bust. Finding quality affordable 100% wool sweaters is like trolling for a record fish…

My favorite sweater?

I picked this one up at a second hand store for 5 dollars about four years ago. I think it’s my only sweater that’s not 100% wool.

026-2.jpg

001-5.jpg

002-4.jpg


I used a bone white sweater for photos because the identical one in blue isn’t very photogenic. It’s a J.G. Glover and made in England. After the sale price and 20% off coupon, it was $45.

032.jpg

040.jpg

043.jpg


If you’re not familiar with wool, I strongly suggest a second hand shop for a bargain sweater.

Good luck,
C&S
 
Last edited:
I think you should purchase a few ranges of surplus balnkets before you hike out a lot of money, and investigate the options for making your own shirt jacket even if you don't like the blanket itself.

The Italian wool blanket is supposed to be very good. But I haven't bought one myself.

The UK army issue one is crap and only about 2mm thick, Not enough for cold weather but it is light. (well lighter than the next one) I am turning mine into a shirt at some point soon.

The Dutch army blanket is still cheap but it's like 5mm thick. And very very warming. I have found the best way to use it, is to wrap itself up like a burito, tie the end with a jam knot and slip into it like a sleeping bag. It's toasty, but can still be used as a poncho liner, ground mat etc. I value the versatility and traditional nature of it.
 

Back
Top