Chainsaw recommendations- stihl or husqvarna


weaselrunner

Scout
Joined
Feb 13, 2011
Messages
700
Likes
2,163
Moved at the turn of the year to a brick rancher on a little over an acre. Somebody in the past had a thing for crepe myrtles. I have a bunch to cut down and a few other trees. Looking at the 2 above brands. Reviews are all over the place depending on the site, from avoid to no brainer. Need some real input, i want a gas powered with a 16 to 18" bar.
Thanks

Also, anybody have a good way of killing those myrtles. Roots are going to be a problem in the future.
 
I think either brand is gonna be fine for you, it’s kinda like asking “Ford or Chevy”. I have a Husqvarna 450 Rancher with an 18” bar and it’s been awesome. I’m sure you’ll get all kinds of recommendations (altho my guess is Stihl will be most popular).

Afraid I can’t help you with the myrtles tho
 
I've been happy with the Stihl pro series saws . Friend of mine works for the USFS and that is all they use , seems to be the standard for all the hotshots and crews they work with on fires/calls. Have a MS361 that is a beast and handles almost anything I'd run across with ease . Sure husky makes a good product but I've not seen any reason to change .
 
If it helps my Milwaukee friend has a Stihl and my DeWalt buddy has a Husqvarna.

I’m on my second Husqy; dropped from a 455 Rancher to a 350 and went shorter with an 18” bar. Both of mine came from a tool rental shop that does service and repair so they were used and abused, but also well maintained.
 
Ran the same echo for 20 years roughly cutting firewood each year.
Replaced it with a pawnshop stihl and I'm impressed with the chain speed for cutting.
We also have another echo 14" for light stuff, and it's a breeze to start and use.

Never owned a huskyvarnee, but I think you will be good with any of the three for what you're talking about.
 
Both brands are pretty interchangeable.... I have owned both, and abused the daylights out of both brands, and they just keep cutting.... Both brands have three distinct lines.... a low-priced Homeowner line, a mid-range medium duty line (Rancher for Husky and Farm Boss for Stihl), and a high priced Professional line.... for your stated use, the mid range would seem to be the ticket. The saws in both companies in the middle range come with variations of the Half chisel tooth design, which is in line with your task There are also electric saws from both brands. Those have some variations in capabilities, and are mostly lighter duty saws that I don't think I'd use for more than light duty limbing... some guys who do the aerial stuff with trees like the electric saws because they're not running until you pull the trigger.... you're never balancing on a shaky limb trying to start your saw. And speaking of light duty saws.... I'm not a fan of any of the minor brands of saws.... Echo's, Homelights, Toros, Craftsman.... Buying a quality saw the first time around is always a good idea...

Think about a spare chain and bar for each saw you're running.... and a sharpening kit.... I have a vise and holder that slides into the trailer hitch on my truck to expedite sharpening.... Crepe Myrtles are hardwood trees, but they're actually softer than some pinewood...... Make sure you ask for Half Chisel chains for your -spares... they're a more forgiving and easily managed chain.... I stick with the same brand replacement chain as the saw.... Though a lot of guys out in the woods do use the Oregon brand bars and replacement chains.... I stick with Husky for Husky and Stihl for Stihl.... Same with fuel.... These days when you buy your saw, you can get a guarantee/warrantee/ protection plan.... that plan is extended if you also buy the branded pre mixed gas.... it doesn't hurt, you don't have to do anything but shake the can up a little to use the stuff, and if you manage to bungle your saw, having that slip that says you were using the same brand of gas mix as the saw.... makes customer service a bit less of a hassle....

Buy two or three times as many wedges as you think you may need.... and have a midsized one hand sledge hammer handy.... if your blade gets stuck, it's usually pretty easy to bang in a wedgie or two and free the blade up.... A bar wrench usually doubles as a spark plug wrench, and having one handy along with a couple spare spark plugs is always easier than running all the way back out of the woods and down to the nearest NAPA to see if you can remember what plug fits your saw.... If your blade is really really stuck, and the wedgies don't help get the saw out, you can use the bar wrench to remove the bar and toss another bar onto your main saw so you can cut your saw blade out.... If your saw gets stuck in a really dicey situation, some times its nice to be able separate your expensive saw from a more replaceable bar and put the saw in a safe zone where it won't get mangled when everything turns southwards...

Did I mention your BUS.... (It's like a BUG only is not a gun its a saw....!) Back up saws are a thing.... depending on how many trees you're dropping, a few extra saws floating around can be a huge driver for continuous operations.... NOT so you can be dropping two trees at once (HUGE safety issue.... work one tree at a time... if it gets hung up on another tree, it is never a good idea to cut the standing tree and drop two trees... ) , but more so you can maintain momentum and not have to muss and fuss too much to free a stuck saw or a fouled plug.... Other momentum savers are various log handling tools.... I'm an old guy, I like Pickeroons, a good log jack... they just make handling trees and chunks of trees easier, and have saved my back much wear and tear.... Chain saw chaps are a real good idea.... realize that chaps that will protect you from a gas saw may not protect you so well from an electric saw.... a good hard hat, a good face shield (I like screens better... they don't fog...) Ear pro and good gloves, too...

We don't have a lot of those trees up north.... not sure how old they are, or if they've grown much past the ornamental stages.... but unless they've grown old and unruly, they should be pretty easily handled. As far as the stumps, Hardwood trees have a lower absorption rate than pines and variations... so killing roots and shoots takes a little longer, and usually calls for stronger herbicides. Around here that means glyphosates.... mostly you've gotta have a license to use them, and you need to be very careful about ground water and your well when using glyphosate and derivitives... The herbicides you can get at the Depot or Tractor Supply are usually polyphinal derivatives.... Copper nails.... you'll need a whole whole whole bunch of them, and they're significantly slower than either of the above methods.... Pulling the stumps out is probably better than grinding them down, as far as preventing new shoots from springing forth... always pull a stump straight up rather than to one side or the other...

Wish you well!!!!
 
Moved at the turn of the year to a brick rancher on a little over an acre. Somebody in the past had a thing for crepe myrtles. I have a bunch to cut down and a few other trees. Looking at the 2 above brands. Reviews are all over the place depending on the site, from avoid to no brainer. Need some real input, i want a gas powered with a 16 to 18" bar.
Thanks

Also, anybody have a good way of killing those myrtles. Roots are going to be a problem in the future.


They are both good saws. I have a half dozen or more Stihl, and a couple of Huskies. I use a chainsaw at least a couple times a week, pretty much year round.

I'd personally recommend a used, somewhat older saw. They often come up for sale on marketplace fairly reasonable. Usually someone will have bought it for cleaning up storm damage or light use and then it just sits. That's what I'd look for.

Whatever you do, run nothing but premium non ethanol fuel, and Stihl oil, even in a Husky.

Another piece of advice from someone who really uses a saw a lot. Don't get a huge saw. :) In my experience, most people get way more of a saw than they need. My main use saws right now is an older Stihl 026 with an 18in bar for felling, and a Stihl 021 for limbing and most bucking. I have bigger saws that I rotate usage, but cutting with these two is never felt like I need more power.

A huge thing in saw use, is learning how to sharpen and maintain your chain. A small saw that is really sharp will outcut a big saw with a dull chain any day.

Let us know what you end up with.

As tp your myrtles. I guess I'd try get the roots out. Digging and chopping and pulling out with a vehicle. Maybe rent a mini excavator and dig them out? I guess a lot depends on how bad you want them gone. Cut them low and rent a stump grinder to get things smooth and flat and then just mow down anything that sprouts?
 
I woods ported a husky 345. And wow is that a rip snorter of a saw. Took it in for a new sprocket and thr mechanic mentioned how well it cut. I got lucky

I currently have 10 different saws. Even though I'm in a different place in life now. At one time a chainsaw was my most important tool. Used one daily
 
Moved at the turn of the year to a brick rancher on a little over an acre. Somebody in the past had a thing for crepe myrtles. I have a bunch to cut down and a few other trees. Looking at the 2 above brands. Reviews are all over the place depending on the site, from avoid to no brainer. Need some real input, i want a gas powered with a 16 to 18" bar.
Thanks

Also, anybody have a good way of killing those myrtles. Roots are going to be a problem in the future.
If you live where it’s cold Stihl is the way to go. Huskies seem to be a bit finicky to start in deep cold. Deep cold such as single digits.
 
Last edited:
I've been happy with the Stihl pro series saws . Friend of mine works for the USFS and that is all they use , seems to be the standard for all the hotshots and crews they work with on fires/calls. Have a MS361 that is a beast and handles almost anything I'd run across with ease . Sure husky makes a good product but I've not seen any reason to change .
Your 100% on that 361.


For a 60cc class saw, it is a beast!
 
Im a stihl guy.
I think they make a better product, that, I believe, lasts longer.

Their pro saws are something else.

They market 3 lines of saws. Homeowner, Farm and Ranch, and the Pro level.

Only difference between Homeowner and farm/ranch is displacement. Both are made on same lines.
Now, the pro saws are a whole different animal. Mag cases, adjustable oiler, 2 peice sprockets, and some other stuff I cant remember. I own a few of each, and have run all types of em. I really love the pro! Dont run a saw full time or as a job anymore, but I do feel most any Stihl ya choose is gonna serve ya well.
Keep em clean. Run proper fuel. Keep em sharp and tuned. Use your PPE and your head....running a saw is fun!!
 
I buy based on the dealer and their service after the sale. Both are fine saws
I ran Stihl for over 20 years and switched to Husqvarna for this exact reason. Well, and the better / cleaner air intake system

I run a 372xp with 24-30" bar depending on how big the timber is that I'm cutting.
 
Moved at the turn of the year to a brick rancher on a little over an acre. Somebody in the past had a thing for crepe myrtles. I have a bunch to cut down and a few other trees. Looking at the 2 above brands. Reviews are all over the place depending on the site, from avoid to no brainer. Need some real input, i want a gas powered with a 16 to 18" bar.
Thanks

Also, anybody have a good way of killing those myrtles. Roots are going to be a problem in the future.
Ive used RM-43 herbicide to kill small trees and shoots. Drill a few 1/2" holes in em, apply RM liberaly. Its non selective, so be careful with this stuff. It kills pretty much anything. Its 43% gly, dont get it on your skin, eyes, etc.
In VA, you do need to be licensed to apply commercially, Registered Tech, at the minimum, but I can buy and use on private property. (Same with fertilizers)

Small bushes, shrubs and shoots , ive just painted the RM right on it. It has another chemical , that acts as a long lasting pre-emergant. Amazapyr? I think thats how to spell it?

I've also had great luck with this stuff on poison ivy, damn near everything ive sprayed it on
 
I am a forestry contractor, mainly performing thinning treatments in Northern New Mexico. Most of the trees I cut are under 12" diameter. I run Stihl saws, mainly because there are no Husqvarna dealers / service centers in my area. I really love the Stihl 261. I use a 20" bar but 18" is also great and more commonly seen on that model. The 261 is a great combination of power and light weight. I run a 462 when getting into bigger wood.
 
For about 25 years, I used a Jonsered chain saw for firewood and occasional tree removal. A local dealer sold and serviced them.
About 5 years ago they switched to Stihl....I now have a MS-260 and a MS-462....
The 260 will do 95% of everything I want a chainsaw for....I just wanted a bigger saw....so I got the 462....
If I just had one....it would be the 260.... The 462 is great for large tree felling....overkill for my firewood work....IMHO....YMMV
 
I'm a Stihl fan, starting with the original 041 Farm Boss in mid 70's, I worked at farm repair shop that sold Stihl for 10-12 years, I currently own 3 Stihl saws one Husqvarna, and one little Echo that I bought for a saw to abuse and not tear up my little Stihl 170. (Wife claims 170 so I just wanted cheap saw to abuse)
I have been very impressed with that little Echo so if I needed another bigger saw I'd seriously consider Echo.
Both Stihl and Echo have good dealers in my area, Husqvarna hasn't had dealer in my area for for over 20 years, so I wouldn't buy a new one, I would choose brand that has good dealer in your area.
We made fun of those Echos years ago when I was pulling wrenches, I sure wouldn't now that I've owned a little Echo 3410 for 2 or 3 years.
KIMG0798.JPGKIMG0760.JPG
 
If it helps, yesterday my good neighbor had me cut his Stihl out of a tree for him with my Husqvarna... He managed to drop the tree with it still embedded in the trunk and bent his bar about 25 degrees...

So there you have it, I imagine both Stihl and Husqvarna can not survive a tree falling on them. ;)

Both good brands... I just couldn't afford the Stihl (good horsepower) so I bought a Husqvarna that has preformed admirably. I don't have an Echo chainsaw, but their weedeaters have been great.
 
Haven’t used a different saw in years. Still running the Evolution series of Echos.

Back when I worked in the woods guys liked both the Stihl and the Husqvarna saws. The only difference I can remember was the Husqvarna was cold blooded and it was made with less parts. So us loggers had less parts to worry about keeping on hand if a saw needed to be worked on.

You will be fine with either.
 
I see many comments about what dealer you have in the area. Other than buying a new saw, why is that important to you? I can see for warranty work on a new saw.

I'm lucky, in that the only saw shop around here sells both Stihl and Husky. In all of my years of sawing, I've only had to go to the shop for new chains or files. I've never had to have any repairs done on any of my equipment.
 

Back
Top